The Court of Justice rules on the imposition of a flat-rate fine for all offences under the rules on the obligation to make prior payment of the toll for use of a road infrastructure
The requirement of proportionality according to Directive 1999/62/EC precludes a system of penalties that provides for the imposition of a flat-rate fine or financial penalty for all offences, whatever their nature and gravity, under the rules on the obligation to make prior payment of the toll for use of a road infrastructure, including where that system provides for the possibility of being exempted from administrative criminal liability by paying a flat-rate redress charge